I might be joining you as being labled a CDPR hater by saying that their hype for Cyberpunk wasn't warranted because I think they've made maybe 2-3 good games that being witcher 3, the standalone Gwent game and maybe witcher 2 (haven't played it yet). So in conclusion I'd agree, this game isn't a masterpiece, but it could be for many people who overlook the bugs, kinda like skyrim except I'd say the ps4 version doesn't have bugs anywhere close to witcher 3. I think one of the reasons I liked the game so much was because of the Gwent card game, which spawned the standalone gwent game. But in deathmarch everything hits like a truck, so you really need to know how to use your signs and have all your potions prepared before battle. If you play on lower difficulties you can literally get though everything blindfolded. If you think the combat isn't good I'd suggest playing on deathmarch difficulty where all of your actions matter. I played the GOTY edition at the start of 2019 on ps4 pro when I'm guessing all the patches were out, but got about 4 game crashes over my 70 hour playthrough with ALOT of bugs. I'd personally give the game a 9/10 (if it weren't for bugs I'd give it 10).

Mon 29th Nov TBH I agree with you in some regards.

Witcher 3 pc goty